Well, after a morning of breaking down and hauling out furniture, the time had finally come for baking! My dad was looking forward to these cookies as he likes butterscotch and I was excited to use a brown butter recipe. I don't have that many recipes that call for browning the butter, but the few that I do have I love the taste, so I am excited about this one as well. I personally am not the biggest fan of butterscotch. It is okay, but not high on my lists of flavors that I love. The last time I made something butterscotch was last summer when working at the ranch. I made chocolate butterscotch pudding pies, 4 of them to be exact. The group of guests there that week did not all want dessert, so I wound up with 2 whole pies leftover. Well, I am not much of a hugger and when a co-worker decided to sneak a bear hug in while I was holding a pie, well.... let's just say he got a pie in the face. Another co-worker threw the last pie in the other cooks face, and weeeeell, we all ended up with pie all over the kitchen (and I mean ALL over the kitchen) and all over ourselves! Hahaha, at least the guests were entertained with the after-dinner-pre-square-dance shenanigans of the kitchen! :)
![]() |
not a hugger. |
Sidetracked, again, sheesh. Back to my cookies. So these cookies are fairly basic, but that is what makes them wonderful. It doesn't take that much extra time to brown the butter, and the rest of the recipe comes together quickly. The cookies are small cookies, perfect for 2 bites! I started once again with my mis en place of my ingredients and searched for a pan that I could see my butter browning in well.
![]() |
butter, brown sug, salt, eggs, vanilla, flour, b.soda, b.powder, kosher salt |
So the recipe starts off with browning the butter. A few times I have been baking or cooking and people come in and say "Ooooh, that smells so good, what is it?" only to find out that I hadn't gotten much else started than some butter in a pan or some melted butter to brush on something. Butter, while people shy from it for fattening reasons, is a smell many people find comforting and tasty no matter what. Browning butter does that same thing.
I put the butter in the pan and watched it foam up at first, and as it kept melting and turning brown, the smells were just wonderful!
Don't believe me? Try this recipe. Brown the butter as it calls for, and see if anyone in your house comes to see what you're making with their lips smacking as they walk in the kitchen!
I tried to be better with getting more pictures today, so the next few are of the dough mixing up. Since the butter is already melted, it definitely incorporated more easily (at least for me) with the eggs than unmelted butter does.
![]() |
look at those eggs mix in! |
Following the recipe, I added the flour in thirds and mixed it til it was all incorporated.
It looked a bit crumbly and dry to me, but when I took a handful in my hand it seemed to clump together okay, so I went with it.
I got the first batch ready and in the oven, but by the end of rolling and dredging for that first tray, the dough was already drying out a bit. I added a little water to moisten it up, and then it was perfect. In the 10 minutes it took for the first batch to bake, I had rolled out the next batch.
![]() |
sprinkled with kosher salt on top. |
As these cookies came out of the oven, they smelled amazing! They had a crunch on the outside and a little chewiness on the inside that was a perfect combination together! They melting in my mouth as my taste testing dad and I tried fresh out of the oven and I already was wishing I had made a bigger batch.
![]() |
these smell so good!!! |
Dad had his with a cup of coffee and I had mine with a cold glass of milk. No matter what you are having them with, they quickly disappear, yummy!
On the taste scale of 1-10, this cookie would get a 9. I thought it was a perfect bite-sized cookie that I know will be on my cookie list for the holidays, or just anytime really! :)